First-Party Cookies vs Third-Party Cookies: What Marketers Need to Know in 2025

In today’s digital marketing landscape, understanding the differences between first-party cookies vs third-party cookies is crucial for modern marketers navigating the changing digital landscape. As privacy concerns grow and regulations tighten, it’s essential to adapt our strategies to respect user preferences while still delivering personalized experiences.

This guide will walk you through the key differences, implications, and best practices for using cookies in your marketing efforts.

Cookie Types Explained: First-Party and Third-Party Differences

Before diving into the implications for marketers, let’s clarify what these cookie types are and how they differ.

First-Party Cookies

First-party cookies are created and stored by the website you’re visiting directly. They serve several important functions:

• Remembering user preferences and settings

• Keeping users logged in

• Storing items in shopping carts

• Providing a personalized experience on that specific site

For example, when you visit an online store and it remembers your login information or keeps items in your cart, that’s the work of first-party cookies.

Third-Party Cookies

Third-party cookies, on the other hand, are created by domains other than the one you’re visiting. They are primarily used for:

• Tracking users across multiple websites

• Serving targeted ads based on browsing history

• Retargeting campaigns

• Gathering data for ad networks and data management platforms

If you’ve ever seen an ad for a product you viewed on another site, that’s likely the result of third-party cookies in action.

The type of cookie you use can significantly impact your ability to track user behavior and deliver targeted marketing messages. While third-party cookies have been a staple of digital advertising for years, their days are numbered due to growing privacy concerns.

Privacy Concerns: The Driving Force Behind Cookie Changes

As privacy concerns grow, marketers must adapt their strategies to respect user preferences while still delivering personalized experiences. The push for greater online privacy has led to significant changes in how cookies can be used:

• Browser changes: Major browsers like Chrome, Firefox, and Safari are phasing out or blocking third-party cookies.

• User awareness: Consumers are becoming more aware of data collection practices and demanding greater control over their information.

• Regulatory pressure: Laws like GDPR in Europe and CCPA in California are setting new standards for data protection and user consent.

Data Protection Regulations: GDPR, CCPA, and Their Impact on Cookies

Understanding data protection regulations like GDPR and CCPA is crucial for compliant and effective use of cookies in marketing. These regulations have had a significant impact on how marketers can collect and use data:

GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation)

• Requires explicit consent for data collection

• Gives users the right to access and delete their data

• Imposes strict penalties for non-compliance (up to €20 million or 4% of global turnover)

CCPA (California Consumer Privacy Act)

• Allows consumers to opt-out of data sales

• Requires businesses to disclose what personal information they collect

• Gives consumers the right to request deletion of their data

These regulations have made it more challenging to rely on third-party cookies for data collection and targeting, pushing marketers to explore alternative strategies.

Best Practices for Adapting to a Cookieless Future

As we face cookie deprecation, marketers must develop new strategies for user identification and personalization. Here are some best practices to help you adapt:

1. Focus on first-party data collection: Implement strategies to gather data directly from your audience through surveys, account creation, and on-site behavior tracking.

2. Leverage contextual advertising: Instead of relying on user tracking, target ads based on the content of the pages they appear on.

3. Explore alternative identification methods: Look into solutions like Universal IDs or first-party identity graphs that don’t rely on third-party cookies.

4. Prioritize user privacy: Be transparent about your data collection practices and give users control over their information.

5. Invest in customer relationships: Focus on building direct relationships with customers through email marketing, loyalty programs, and personalized content.

Leveraging Personal Data: First-Party Cookie Strategies

Implementing best practices for first-party data collection will be key to success in a post-third-party cookie world. Here are some strategies to effectively leverage personal data collected through first-party cookies:

1. Create value exchanges: Offer something of value (e.g., exclusive content, discounts) in exchange for user data.

2. Personalize on-site experiences: Use first-party data to tailor content, product recommendations, and offers to individual users.

3. Segment your audience: Use the data you collect to create detailed audience segments for more targeted marketing.

4. Enhance email marketing: Use first-party data to send more relevant, personalized email campaigns.

5. Improve ad targeting: While you can’t track users across sites, you can use first-party data to create lookalike audiences for ad platforms.

Balancing User Experience and Data Collection in the Cookie Era

Effective cookie strategies require balancing data collection with user experience. Transparency is key — clearly communicate data practices, offer simple opt-in/out options, and highlight the benefits of data sharing to build trust.

Gradual data collection through progressive profiling prevents overwhelming users, while regular audits keep data relevant and compliant. These practices help maintain user satisfaction and optimize marketing efforts.

Preparing for Cookie Deprecation: What Marketers Should Do Now

With the shift toward a cookieless future, marketers need proactive strategies. Start by auditing your current cookie usage to identify necessary changes, and invest in infrastructure for collecting and managing first-party data.

Experiment with alternative targeting methods like contextual advertising, and ensure your team is educated and ready to adapt. Stay informed about emerging technologies and industry trends to navigate this transition effectively.

Conclusion

While the deprecation of third-party cookies presents challenges, it also offers opportunities for marketers to build more direct, trust-based relationships with their audiences. By focusing on first-party data, prioritizing user privacy, and adapting to new technologies and regulations, marketers can thrive in this new era of digital marketing.

Book a meeting with our CEO to learn how Surface Labs can provide first-party data, lead enrichment and many more cool things for your business.